I'm in very much the same situation, with the same wishlist. In addition to the 10" rough-in I only have 29" from my wall to the door swing. I figure at most I can have 28" depth for the toilet
including the space between the tank and wall. The tank-wall gap tripped me up before, and I had set my heart on squeezing a Guinevere in. This all but eliminates the elongated options, and it looks like the ADAs too, unfortunately.
After reading the forum, I feel like my choices are:
- Toto 10" Drake CST744EF.10
- Gerber Viper
- Gerber Ultraflush
- Niagara flapperless
- American Cadet 3 RF 10" -- Terry, you mentioned there's a tall version. Do you have a model number? I can't find mention of it.
- (Possibly) American Standard compact space saver? When I was at HD I thought I saw that it could be combined with an EL bowl to fit a 10" rough, but maybe it's not worth it.
Is a Toto still a Toto despite the splashing? I think I read some good reviews of the
Ultraflush as well as the Cadet 3, but I'm unsure about AS in general. The others are hard to find reviews for.
It seems like none of these are "top" performers, which is disappointing, but could people who've had experience with these toilets provide guidance? All the usual criteria: performance, clogging, bowl wash, noise, splash, replacement parts, anything else... Thanks!
TOTO Guinevere pedestal lav and toilet suite