Well I got the 3" but turns out the old cast iron is actually larger than 3"... I guess it is a 3.5" CO so the 3" worked but leaked the whole time. I will now return it and get a 4" which has a range starting at 3.5" so should work better.
Btw, the product gives incredible warnings of death and other horrors... didn't know any of that when I rented one... but getting it new gives all the warnings. What is the danger of these things? Just if you over inflate it or is it that it will launch like a bullet from back pressure or what? OR just more CYA stuff from lawyers?