https://terrylove.com/forums/index.php?threads/about-new-water-heater-no-rotten-egg-smell.77342/#post-571874 states my thoughts on why a long anode would be better than a short anode.I'm looking into buying a powered anode for my current Geosprings water heater as my new house also has a water softener and I don't want to replace a sacrificial anode every year or two. I'm currently leaning towards the AO Smith one that Otto Mation posted.