Dripping tub spout

[HotHat]

I replaced a broken diverter spout a few weeks ago, and it went great. But two weeks ago—about 3 weeks after the replacement—it started dripping. First, it dripped longer and longer after baths and showers, but that’s increased to a constant, rapid drip, day and night.

I’d read it could be caused by not using enough thread tape, so yesterday I took it all apart to redo the tape, and found the pipe/nipple itself had a constant flow of water when I removed the spout. Water was off, and pressure relieved throughout the house as when I did it originally, but the first time, the pipe was dry.

Since it’s just dripping from the tip and no water is in the wall, I put the spout back on so we can keep using it.

So first, how could water be coming out in the tub when all the water in the house was off?

And where might the problem be? Did replacing the spout break something else? I’m a novice, so is it something I can still fix myself?

Specs: 1/2” iron threaded pipe, simple diverter spout replaced with the same type

https://www.us.kohler.com/us//productDetail/tub-spout/637981.htm

 

[Reach4]

The problem is not the diverter, but rather is a problem with the valve(s). If old 2-knob type, replace the seat(s) and washer(s).

If it is a single knob on-off, you would possibly repair, or, more likely, replace the cartridge.

 

[Sponsor]

 

[HotHat]

Thanks, I’m glad that’s it—even I can figure that out, with enough youtube research.

Curious: do you think it’s just a coincidence this started so soon after the spout replacement? We’ve been in this house 21 years with no tub issues, so it seems odd.

 

[Reach4]

Curious: do you think it’s just a coincidence this started so soon after the spout replacement? We’ve been in this house 21 years with no tub issues, so it seems odd.

I think so. Maybe wiggling pipes could have had an effect, but I would lean toward coincidence.

 

[HotHat]

I think so. Maybe wiggling pipes could have had an effect, but I would lean toward coincidence.

Follow up: turns out, my faucets have the rubber seats with springs, and one seat won’t come out of the pipe. Any suggestions for removing it?

I’ve tried 2 sizes of needlenose pliars, then an allen wrench and a couple of screwdrivers to try to pry it from the center of the hole, and it won’t budge. it sits about 1.5” behind the wall, so not much fits.

 

[Reach4]

How about a closeup photo of the one that did come out.

Rubber things in faucet valves are usually called washers, and seats are usually metal. But the springs in valves, I am not familiar with.

A hook and pick set might be what you would want, but you might need something stronger or special.

 

[Terry]

We’ve been in this house 21 years with no tub issues, so it seems odd.

21 years without replacing any parts? You were due for some maintenance.

And we have no idea of what brand you're working with.

 

[HotHat]

this is what i’ve got: https://www.danco.com/product/universal-seats-and-springs-for-delta-single-handle-faucets/#
...though i have no idea what brand since nothing is labeled and they came with the house.

i’m trying to rig a hook with a paperclip right now.

 

[HotHat]

...and that did it. Thanks for your help!