When to repair - when to replace?

shendrick · Dec 30, 2012

I've got a 10 year old Sear Power Miser gas hot water heater. it's never had the anode changed and now we're getting yellow hot water. I'm guessing that the yellow water means that the anode is shot and the tank is rusting. If yellow water is a symptom of the tank rusting, I would assume the only option is to replace. Do I have this right?

JohnjH2o1 · Dec 30, 2012

If it's been ten years since you purchased a gas water heater your in for some sticker shock.

John

Sponsor · 2022-01-29T12:20:58-0800

shendrick · Dec 30, 2012

I know, it will be about $1K for the heater plus a few hundred for installation. Question remains, is it really time to replace or would a new anode do the trick?

Jadnashua · Dec 30, 2012

If the yellow is rust, it's unlikely a new anode will resolve the problem. But, first, is the hot water colored at every outlet? If not, it's not the WH, but likely the piping to the thing that does have the yellow water.

shendrick · Dec 30, 2012

Yes, yellow at every hot water outlet.

Terry · Dec 30, 2012

That may be more than an anode rod.
One thing you may do is connect a hose to the drain and see if you can flush the tank out.

shendrick · Dec 30, 2012

Terry, thanks for the advice. The literature says something about a swirl acthitecture, so I'm going to assume that the significant yellow that we see is more than just sediment. After 10 years, I would suspect that the liner is cracked given how much yellow we see. I could fuss around with an anode, but it feels like a bandaid solution that buys me some extra months - not years. I guess its time for a do over before we need to build an ark.

Terry · Dec 30, 2012

Generally, if you have an issue with a water heater that is ten years or older, it's better to just replace it.
Not much bang for the buck doing a band aid job.
And I can say that because I did just that for my own home years ago. The band aid lasted two months.

shendrick · Dec 31, 2012

Great advice, thanks for the help.

hj · Dec 31, 2012

IF a new anode rod would have prevented the condition, and that is not likely, then it is too late for that now. Once the tank starts rusting, an anode rod cannot stop it.

When to repair - when to replace?

shendrick

New Member

JohnjH2o1

Plumbing Contractor for 49 years

Sponsor

Paid Advertisement

shendrick

New Member

Jadnashua

Retired Defense Industry Engineer xxx

shendrick

New Member

Terry

The Plumbing Wizard

shendrick

New Member

Terry

The Plumbing Wizard

shendrick

New Member

hj

Master Plumber

Similar threads