To each his own. I have had great success doing it the same old way for many years. I never ownen a rotary, so I never owned a compresser. Pumping with a Bremer and Plunger always made a good well for me. As far as pulling and letting a column of water fall, that's the same as surging for the most part, and even though I did try it on a few stubborn aquifers, it proved to be totally inefficient for me.
You can read the Army Corp of Engineers handbook too if you like, but I think you'll find out that experience in your own area is the best teacher.
bob...