Seahawk Highlights Video (206) 949-5683, Top Rated Plumber, Seattle

1. Basement heating?

About ready to drywall the basement. I'm starting to think about heating options. The temp is always pretty comfortable down there. I was thinking about electric baseboard. The house has forced hot water Weil McLain (5 years old) 2 zone set up. Wondering how difficult it would be to have a plumber see if it can be run as a 3 zone?

2. Model number on that Weil McLain is...? And fuel type?

Heat loads in basements are pretty tiny, especially if insulated the basement properly (?) as part of finishing it off.

When you have a boiler serving a tiny heat load you often have to up-size the radiation to keep it from short-cycling the boiler, but given the MA prices for natural gas vs. electricity it's still worth it to go with the hydronic solution.

But let's have the particulars first.

Fuel type

Boiler model/make size

Insulation & window details on the basement to estimate the load.

3. I'll have to get the model number when I get home.
Runs off gas. 3 windows in the basement. 2 full size windows (walk out basement) and one of those little basement windows. The basement exterior walls are all insulated.

4. How is the foundation insulated? (Hopefully not just a studwall up against the concrete with kraft-faced R13s, unless you were planning on getting into the mold farming biz.)

Window glazing type, and sizes?

Depending on how the whole thing is insulated, the U-factor of the walls will be somewhere between 0.07 and 0.12 BTU per square foot per degree-F. For a rough order of magnitude number, just assume a U-factor 0.1. If the walk-out wall is a 2x6 R19 wall, call that wall U0.07

sq. ft x U0.1 x 65F= xxxx

If the windows are all clear glass double panes, not low-E, not gas-filled, call it U0.5. (If single pane, call it U 1.0 ). Then multiply:

sq ft x 0.5 x 65F= yyyy

Any 2" solid wood doors are also about U 0.5, measure it up, multiply that out.

Add it all up, and you'll have a pretty good rough idea of the heat load when there is a 65F delta-T, say when the interior is 70F, exterior is +5F (the 99% outside design temp for Worcester).

Then you'll be pretty close to the real heat load number- we can add fudge factors for air infiltration and the below grade losses to that for good measure, but most insulated walk-out basements will be well under 10,000 BTU/hr, and very likely will run in the sub-5K range. But run the numbers to see where yours lives.

With a zip code (for a more precise outside design temp and delta-T) and better wall stackup/insulation details we can refine it a bit, but it won't change a huge amount from the crude load numbers. If the boiler and hot water heater are in the basement, their standby losses can be subtracted off the heat load directly, but again, it's not going to change substantially. The issue in 99% of the cases is to provide enough radiation or thermal mass to keep the boiler from short-cycling. The "right" hydronic solution will be a function of both the boiler output and the heat load. When the zone load is tiny relative to the boiler output you have to play some games, but there is always some sort of solution.

5. Thanks. That's way over my head. I'll just call the plumber I know and have him take a look.
No it's not studs up against concrete. They are studs spaced 4.5 to 5 inches off the wall. It's a walkout and not a damp basement.

6. It's a weil mclain gold cgi 4 pin
http://www.weil-mclain.com/en/multim...gi/cgi_lit.pdf

7. FWIW, lots of hvac guys are great and know their stuff, but there's also a bunch out there that, while they may be good mechanics, have no clue on how to size and optimize what they put in...it's best to run some numbers for yourself, then compare with what they suggest...the two may be worlds apart.

8. Originally Posted by moreira85
Thanks. That's way over my head. I'll just call the plumber I know and have him take a look.
No it's not studs up against concrete. They are studs spaced 4.5 to 5 inches off the wall. It's a walkout and not a damp basement.
If you have batts without an exterior side air-barrier into that 4.5-5" gap it will dramatically underperform at the cold temperature extremes due to convective air transfer between the cavity space and the fiber. (An R13 may operate at R8-9 when the cavity area is 25F or lower.)

If the batts have a vapor barrier on the conditioned space side, the framing wood will run at very high humidity levels unless that gap is fully vented to the exterior. It doesn't have to be a "damp basement" for this to be the case- all below grade-walls/slabs have ~100% relative humidity dirt on one side, and vapor diffusion alone will raise the humidity level in the space to nearly the same level over time, if the wall can't dry toward the interior. If your foundation sill & band joist leak enough air that may save you from the mold issue, but that's also a large heat leak.

If you can slip in 2" of rigid EPS foam and glue it to the concrete with foam-board construction adhesive, and can-foam/or Froth-pack seal the EPS to the foundation sill, as well as sealing all seams of the foam board itself, and seal the band joist at the same time, you'll then have a wall that out-performs the fiberglass-in-studs all by itself. In that stackup you'd then be able to use kraft-faced R19 compressed up to the foam and have something that meets/beats current code min for MA basements. IRC 2012 code min for a climate zone 5 MA location is R15 if continuous like the foam, R19 if in a studwall, but R19 in a studwall runs in to wintertime condensation vs. ground moisture accumulation problems. At 2" the EPS is about R8, with compressed R19s you would more than double it but if you left the ~2" gap between foam & R13 you'd add about an other R10 with the R13s. With the foam in place a kraft facer would be sufficiently vapor permeable to manage the ground moisture loads, but unfaced goods would be better.

The more expensive alternative would be to spray 2" of closed cell foam on foundation conrete from the slab right up to and including the foundation sill and band joist, but at \$2 per square foot it adds up fast. R8 EPS runs about 75 cents a square foot, 25 cents/foot if you buy reclaimed roofing foam from folks like the Insulation Depot in Framingham- there are others in MA dealing in reclaimed foam too- cheaper than batts sometimes.

Plumbers aren't usually hydronic heating designers, they don't calculate heat loads, and they know damned little about keeping boilers from short-cycling. The CGI-4 has an output of 85,000 BTU/hr. To balance that perfectly using fin tube at 180F output calls for about 140' of baseboard, and it can probably get away with 80-100' if you bump the high-limit on the boiler to 210F or something. But that is a RIDICULOUS amount of oversizing of the radiation to serving the basement zone that has a max load in the 2-5000 BTU/hr.

What probably makes the most sense is to run the heat load calculation for the basement and put in a generous amount for the space, but use a parallel branch from the first-floor zone, with a zone valve controlled by the basement thermostat for the basement branch. The heat loss characterisics of basements (even walk-outs) don't match upper floor zones well, but any time there is a significant heat load on the basement there would usually be an even more significant load on the first floor, so by oversizing the radiation for the basement and piggy-backing on the first floor zone, but limiting the basement temp with it's own zone valve & thermostat you can probably get decent comfort there without short-cycling the boiler or oversizing the radiation by 10x.

How much radiation is there on the other zones (broken down by zone)?

9. So I have continued to research and take some measurements. In the basement I have about 600 sq feet. You can see the windows there are 2 34x38 windows as well as the door and the little window. The long wall with the windows is above grade and about 32 ft long by 7.5 feet tall. It stays very comfortable in the basement around 65 maybe even when it's freezing out. I want to install the baseboard now so I can boost the temp a little. Currently in the house we have 112ft of baseboard being run on two zones. I was estimating maybe 14000 btu for the basement since it is well insulated? House is 6 yrs old.

10. A few more pics

11. A gross over complication of a simple problem. Stick 20' of baseboard down there on its own thermostat and zone valve and forget about it. Some of these guys want to make a science project out of everything. You don't need to do a heat loss.

12. Tending to like Tom Sawyer's keep-it-simple-stupid approach, but make sure you leave yourself a way to add more baseboard later if 20' turns out to not be enough. The trouble with shooting from the hip is the chance of missing the target. The heat loss calculation tries to take the guesswork out of it.

Posting Permissions

• You may not post new threads
• You may not post replies
• You may not post attachments
• You may not edit your posts
•