Solenoid Failure?

Users who are viewing this thread

Kiko

Member
Messages
186
Reaction score
0
Points
16
Location
Royal Oak, Michigan
My parents had a ventless gas log system installed in their fireplace 3 yrs ago, purchased from Lowes. The main burners are ignited by a solenoid located in the gas valve. This solenoid is powered by a remote controlled receiver box wired to the solenoid, which takes 4 AA batteries (six volts).

The burners stopped working and did not work even after fresh batteries were installed in the remote and the receiver. I disconnected the wires to the solenoid and used my voltmeter to check the voltage coming from the box. It read 6 volts in both the "on" and "off" positions, which means the solenoid should be able to open and close, if working properly. I then touched the solenoid wires to the terminals of a 9 volt battery, and the solenoid opened and closed and the burners turned on and off.

I lined up 5 AA batteries (7.5 volts) and the solenoid still worked fine. However, when I removed one of the batteries, the solenoid turned off the burners but would not turn them on unless I increased the voltage.


I have four questions:

1. Why would the solenoid work in one direction, i.e., close, but not open, with 6 volts?

2. Why would increasing the voltage to 7.5 volts allow it to open and close, when it is designed to open and close with 6 volts?

3. Does a solenoid wear out slowly, or does it go all at once?

4. Is there a way to add an additional battery to the receiver, so I don't have to mess with trying to replace the solenoid, if the solenoid is defective?
 
Last edited:

JWelectric

Electrical Contractor/Instructor
Messages
2,608
Reaction score
21
Points
38
Location
North Carolina
1. Why would the solenoid work in one direction, i.e., close, but not open, with 6 volts?
I would guess that it would close without any voltage but not being familiar with the unit I can’ say. I have a gas heater that shuts off the gas during any power failure.

2. Why would increasing the voltage to 7.5 volts allow it to open and close, when it is designed to open and close with 6 volts?
It could be due to an increased resistance in the winding

3. Does a solenoid wear out slowly, or does it go all at once?
It can go either way, slowly or all at once

3. Is there a way to add an additional battery to the receiver, so I don't have to mess with trying to replace the solenoid, if the solenoid is defective?
I am not sure that this would be a good idea
 

Jadnashua

Retired Defense Industry Engineer xxx
Messages
32,770
Reaction score
1,190
Points
113
Location
New England
Some valves have a spring in them, so that can help (often to turn it off) one direction verses the other. It depends on the design. To save power, in this application, it probably swaps the voltage, and it stays (i.e., isn't sprung). The gaskets or bearing that the valve slides through could be worn or corroded.
 

DonL

Jack of all trades Master of one
Messages
5,205
Reaction score
72
Points
48
Location
Houston, TX
If you are only getting 6 Volts from 4 AA Batteries,
Then your batteries are not all that Fresh.

Good Alkaline batteries will be higher than 6.

1.5 V No Load => 50% Dead
 

Kiko

Member
Messages
186
Reaction score
0
Points
16
Location
Royal Oak, Michigan
If you are only getting 6 Volts from 4 AA Batteries,
Then your batteries are not all that Fresh.

Good Alkaline batteries will be higher than 6.

1.5 V No Load => 50% Dead

I was just trying to keep things simple. The four brand new alkalines measured ~6.6 V.
 

Kiko

Member
Messages
186
Reaction score
0
Points
16
Location
Royal Oak, Michigan
Some valves have a spring in them, so that can help (often to turn it off) one direction verses the other. It depends on the design. To save power, in this application, it probably swaps the voltage, and it stays (i.e., isn't sprung). The gaskets or bearing that the valve slides through could be worn or corroded.

The way the receiver box works is that it puts out current in one direction to open the solenoid and reverses the current to close it. I assume this would cause the electromagnet to open and close some kind of ferrous "gate," possibly separate from the valve itself, since the gas valve is maintained in the "open" position at all times with only the pilot flame burning.

Not sure if a spring is involved. My uneducated opinion is that the windings are okay, since the solenoid works in one direction. Perhaps the "gate" gets stuck when trying to open it because something is worn or corroded (as you mentioned.)
 
Last edited:

Kiko

Member
Messages
186
Reaction score
0
Points
16
Location
Royal Oak, Michigan
One final thing. At some point in this "experiment," I wire-nutted in a couple of additional feet of 18 gauge wire to allow the remote box to sit outside of the fireplace (so I wouldn't have to bend over so much).

How can I determine the voltage drop caused by that additional wire?
The initial voltage is 6.6 volts DC and the wire gauge is 18. I don't know what the amperage or the wattage is, but I assume a 6V DC solenoid has a certain wattage rating. I just can't find it.
 
Last edited:

DonL

Jack of all trades Master of one
Messages
5,205
Reaction score
72
Points
48
Location
Houston, TX
One final thing. At some point in this "experiment," I wire-nutted in a couple of additional feet of 18 gauge wire to allow the remote box to sit outside of the fireplace (so I wouldn't have to bend over so much).

How can I determine the voltage drop caused by that additional wire?
The initial voltage is 6.6 volts DC and the wire gauge is 18. I don't know what the amperage or the wattage is.

Without knowing the current then you would just have to measure the Voltage.

I don't think that it would be very much, If you just added a couple feet.

Is it possible that your control box has a bad capacitor in it ?
If it has one you may want to check it.
 

BobL43

DIY Senior Member
Messages
1,802
Reaction score
8
Points
38
Location
Long Island, NY
One final thing. At some point in this "experiment," I wire-nutted in a couple of additional feet of 18 gauge wire to allow the remote box to sit outside of the fireplace (so I wouldn't have to bend over so much).

How can I determine the voltage drop caused by that additional wire?
The initial voltage is 6.6 volts DC and the wire gauge is 18. I don't know what the amperage or the wattage is.
It can't be much current that is drawn, otherwise the battery life would be very short. I have a Vanguard unvented gas firelog that uses a 9 volt battery in the receiver/control and it lasts for several years. Seems unsafe that it would require a voltage to close the (main burner?) valve. the pilot valve is kept open by a themocouple pilot generator device. Hmmm. did you try to contact the manufacturer of this unit?
 

Kiko

Member
Messages
186
Reaction score
0
Points
16
Location
Royal Oak, Michigan
Without knowing the current then you would just have to measure the Voltage.

I don't think that it would be very much, If you just added a couple feet.

Is it possible that your control box has a bad capacitor in it ?
If it has one you may want to check it.

The box is fine. It puts out 6.6 volts in both positions.
To measure the voltage at the other end requires unbolting the unit from the fireplace floor and removing all the logs to get to the solenoid.
 
Last edited:

Kiko

Member
Messages
186
Reaction score
0
Points
16
Location
Royal Oak, Michigan
It can't be much current that is drawn, otherwise the battery life would be very short. I have a Vanguard unvented gas firelog that uses a 9 volt battery in the receiver/control and it lasts for several years. Seems unsafe that it would require a voltage to close the (main burner?) valve. the pilot valve is kept open by a themocouple pilot generator device. Hmmm. did you try to contact the manufacturer of this unit?

The manufacturer is Pro Com, and they haven't been very helpful in either diagnosing the problem or sending replacement parts (still under warranty.)

The remote/receiver is made by SkyTech and they don't make a 9 volt receiver.

I bought some battery holders and may try to add an additional AA battery or replace them all with a 9 volt and see if that will work. I may also just replace the remote with a rocker switch hooked up to a 9 volt if I can find one that puts out current in both the on and off positions. BTW, is there a special name for a switch like that? The good folks at Radio Shack never heard of one.
 

Jadnashua

Retired Defense Industry Engineer xxx
Messages
32,770
Reaction score
1,190
Points
113
Location
New England
An on/off switch just opens in the off position, otherwise, it wouldn't be an on/off switch.

What likely happens in what you have is they swap the polarity of the voltage in one position verses the other, and in the 'off' position, it disconnects it entirely; otherwise, the circuit would be drawing power all the time, and the battery life would be lousy.

Is it a rocker switch, with a 'center' position?
 

Kiko

Member
Messages
186
Reaction score
0
Points
16
Location
Royal Oak, Michigan
The box has three positions: On, off, and remote. When you slide the switch to "on" it puts out 6.5 volts for two seconds to open the solenoid. When you slide it to "off" it swaps polarity and puts out 6.5 volts for two seconds to close the solenoid. In the "remote" position it does the same thing using the remote control buttons to switch on and off. Since it only draws current for a couple of seconds, the batteries last a year or more.
 

Jadnashua

Retired Defense Industry Engineer xxx
Messages
32,770
Reaction score
1,190
Points
113
Location
New England
It's likely a simple switch, but it's an input to an active circuit...i.e., there's a chip in there that's setting up the timing and likely the voltage polarity swap. You can duplicate the function, but it would be up to you to manually make the requried on/off pulse. Keep buggin the manufacturer, as they're the best source to help, especially if it is still under warranty.
 

Kiko

Member
Messages
186
Reaction score
0
Points
16
Location
Royal Oak, Michigan
I've been dealing with the manufacturer for three weeks now, and they keep finding new hoops for me to jump through.

My idea of adding an additional battery in series with the others may work, but I'm not sure if the added currrent will fry the circuit board.
 

JWelectric

Electrical Contractor/Instructor
Messages
2,608
Reaction score
21
Points
38
Location
North Carolina
The circuit board will not pull any more current than what it is designed to draw but the added voltage will cause damage.

Given what you are working on it might be better to have some qualified in the field to work on it than try to do something that it is not designed to do and end up with something that wont work or might even be dangerous.
 

BobL43

DIY Senior Member
Messages
1,802
Reaction score
8
Points
38
Location
Long Island, NY
The circuit board will not pull any more current than what it is designed to draw but the added voltage will cause damage.

Given what you are working on it might be better to have some qualified in the field to work on it than try to do something that it is not designed to do and end up with something that wont work or might even be dangerous.
I agree with JW; as much as we would like to figure out how everything works and fix everything ourselves, sometimes, especially with gas and fire appliances, its not worth it and is very dangerous. Get a gas tech there and let him diagnose it. Problem is, he'll probably tell you to replace the whole gas log; I hope not.
 

hj

Master Plumber
Messages
33,602
Reaction score
1,038
Points
113
Location
Cave Creek, Arizona
Website
www.terrylove.com
A "battery operated valve" HAS to be powered into the on or off position, using some kind of "latching mechanism" to hold it in position. IF the battery had to maintain in in the "ON" position and it defaulted to "OFF" without power the batteries would die in a matter of minutes, or hours, but ALWAYS within a relatively short time frame.
 

BobL43

DIY Senior Member
Messages
1,802
Reaction score
8
Points
38
Location
Long Island, NY
A "battery operated valve" HAS to be powered into the on or off position, using some kind of "latching mechanism" to hold it in position. IF the battery had to maintain in in the "ON" position and it defaulted to "OFF" without power the batteries would die in a matter of minutes, or hours, but ALWAYS within a relatively short time frame.

That does make a lot of sense to me, and I realized that, BUT, if the firelog is lit, and the battery "just happens" to weaken to the point where it does not have enough power to shut off that flame when you want to shut it off, that would require the owner reaching into the fireplace and turning the manual valve knob to "pilot" or "off". May not be extremely dangerous (it is easy to do it though), but it seems like an odd design.

These non vented fireplace logs have an oxygen depletion sensor normally (at least mine does). Would a dead battery prevent the system from shutting down if needed? The pilot has its own millivolt safety system, but I really have not looked into what other safeties are built into these fireplace units. I guess the AGA certifies them all. Well, Canada now may have that responsibilty. All this thread is about the units with a remote control, lke the OP and the one I have, so I guess on a fireplace that is stricly manually controlled by the manual gas valve knob works on the millivolt current going through safeties like any other similar system? I'm interested in learning here too.
 

Kiko

Member
Messages
186
Reaction score
0
Points
16
Location
Royal Oak, Michigan
That does make a lot of sense to me, and I realized that, BUT, if the firelog is lit, and the battery "just happens" to weaken to the point where it does not have enough power to shut off that flame when you want to shut it off, that would require the owner reaching into the fireplace and turning the manual valve knob to "pilot" or "off". May not be extremely dangerous (it is easy to do it though), but it seems like an odd design.

Turning the solenoid off seems to require a lot less voltage than turning it on. So, if the battery started to get weak, you would (in theory) be able to shut the burners, without being able to turn them back on. In fact, that's my whole problem. The latch, which is activated by the solenoid, closes no matter what kind of batteries I use. However, even after I wired a 9 volt to the 6 volt receiver box, the latch eventually got stuck again when I tried to turn on the burners.

Short of hooking up a car battery to the solenoid, :eek: I'm fresh out of ideas and will have to wait for the new parts to come... unless there's a way to take the solenoid apart and lubricate the latch or replace the spring??
 
Last edited:
Top
Hey, wait a minute.

This is awkward, but...

It looks like you're using an ad blocker. We get it, but (1) terrylove.com can't live without ads, and (2) ad blockers can cause issues with videos and comments. If you'd like to support the site, please allow ads.

If any particular ad is your REASON for blocking ads, please let us know. We might be able to do something about it. Thanks.
I've Disabled AdBlock    No Thanks