Greensand Filter - Frequent Clogging

Users who are viewing this thread

Rjh2o

Member
Messages
80
Reaction score
1
Points
8
Location
Michigan
This is all well and good about the Sanitizer, but I prefer something I know from past experience that works everytime. I do not sell something that if this is that way then use this or if it is that way use that. I stay away from medias that are heavy, KDF, Filox, Pyolox...etc because most residental well I have seen don't have enough flow rate to properly backwash these medias. Chlorination is the best way to deal with h2s and high iron.

H2S and iron levels in Florida can be extremely high. Typically a sanitizer is designed to handle up to 5ppm H2S but that is asking a lot of it. I would agree that with high H2S and high iron levels a chlorine injection or hydrogen peroxide injection system would be the best application. An outdoor venting/airation system for high H2S is also an option in warm climates as Florida.
RJ
 

danimal96

New Member
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
Village of Lakewood, IL
Hi all - I finally have my test results back from a local water lab:

TDS: 410 mg/l
pH: 6.6
Hardness: 31 gpg
Iron: .935 mg/l
Nitrate: 0
Nitrite: 0
Copper: .055 mg/l
Lead: .004 mg/l
Sulfate: 110 mg/l
Manganese: .380 mg/l
Iron Bacteria: "Detected" (no level provided)

Well Information (provided for background only - since I found the well report since I originally posted):
23 feet deep well (through clay & sand gravel); 10 gpm pump; 5 inch black steel casing; well was installed in 1988 when the house was built (so 23 years old)

I asked the company if they can provide more details on Iron Bacteria beyond "detected". They provided the following reply:

"The level of concentration using the IRB Bart method was a colony between 9,200 and 2,300 (detection of activity in 5 days)."

I have received the following proposals from local companies (as a reminder - I currently have a 10 y.o. water softener + a Greensand filter which I am looking to replace due to bad flow rate & frequent clogging). I asked each company to quote a RO system as well (which is something new for the house):

Option 1 (local water treatment company):
a) Remove existing Softener & Greensand filter - replace with sediment pre-filter and Kinetico 2060 Softener
b) Kinetico K5 RO system
TOTAL PRICE: $3000

Option 2 (local water treatment company that does a large amount of business in the region):
a) Rebed existing softener, re-size to appropriate level (I think the current system is 32K grains capacity)
b) Chlorine Injection System w/ holding tank
c) RO Unit
TOTAL PRICE $5,000

Option 3 (local independent guy - assembles his own stuff):
a) Keep existing softener (if it ain't broke don't fix it!)
b) Charger Iron Breaker III iron system
c) RO System (Dow/Filmtec media)
TOTAL PRICE: $1,200

Option 4 (Culligan):
a) Culligan HE Softener
b) Culligan Filtr-Cleer Iron Filter (the tech claims that my Iron level is 3 PPM - but that my softener is removing 2 PPM leaving 1 PPM of undissolved iron; only person to tell me that so far!)
c) Culligan Aqua-Cleer w/ Total Defense RO system
TOTAL PRICE: $6,000 (or rent all equipment for $95/month)

My biggest dilemma is - do I pay extra for treatment of Iron Bacteria? The house is 22 years old, and has never had a chlorine system - nor do any of my neighbors who are also on wells. A bit of history - when the Greensand system was working fine (which it did for the first few years) - my water quality was great. I'm leaning against the Kinetico option due to high price ($1K for their RO system alone) and research I've done that leads me to believe that - while quality equipment - it would be the "Cadillac option" and that I'd overpay for what I need (dual tank, 24-hr water, etc).

I'm inclined to go w/ Option 3 (and not only because it's cheapest - but that doesn't hurt!). The guy is small, local, and comes with good references. He assembles his own equipment & has very fair prices compared to the larger companies. When I mention IRB to him, he said that the Iron Breaker system will help overall since the bacteria need iron to feed on, and without iron in the water the impact is lessened. He also said that he has only used a chlorine system a few times due to high prices, upkeep, and the fact that most homes do fine without one.

Option 2 is - I'm guessing - the safest & most comprehensive solution; however $5K is a steep price to pay. Option 4 (Culligan) is pricey and is pretty easy for me to dismiss out of hand...

Any additional advice/questions/suggestions are very much appreciated! I hope to have this decided once & for all soon!
 

Mikey

Aspiring Old Fart, EE, computer & networking geek
Messages
3,024
Reaction score
17
Points
38
Location
Hansville, Washington
I'm not a water treatment expert, nor do I pretend to be one on TV. I've got similar Florida water; quality in the house is excellent, but there's enough residual iron to coat various surfaces (e.g., toilet tanks, dish drainboards) with a thin red coating over time. Also, the spun filter (see below) clogs enough (with iron) to impede flow every couple of months. After talking with a bunch of experts and a neighbor who has the Kinetico system (and disgusting water in the house), I'm going to modify my existing system:

well->pressure tank->chlorine injection->holding tank->spun filter->carbon filter->softener->house

by adding a Greensand filter (with the Autotrol valve), which will result in the following flow:

well->chlorine injection->125gal holding tank->pressure tank->carbon filter->Greensand filter->softener->house

I'm going to plumb in the spun filter (without a cartridge) somewhere, probably just after the softener, just to use as a sight glass, and as a good place to supply chlorine if I should need to chlorinate the house at some time in the future. I like the chlorine injection approach, and it makes my wife less apprehensive when she sees the cows next door peeing in the field. The well is around 200' deep, so cow pee probably isn't a real factor, but WTH. Once chlorine has done its job, however, it's got to be removed so it doesn't screw up subsequent filters, so thus the carbon. I'm not planning on using permanganate, on the advice of my local dealer, but it's easy to add later if it should be necessary. I hope to have it completed in the next few weeks, and will report back.
 

Mialynette2003

In the Trades
Messages
944
Reaction score
17
Points
18
Location
Ocala, Florida
I see where your problem is...well->pressure tank->chlorine injection->holding tank->spun filter->carbon filter->softener->house
When injecting after the pressure tank, the water in the retention tank is being diluted between cut on & cut off. Let's say you have 30 gallons of draw down. You are adding 30 gal of non treated water to the 125 gal retention tank which is bringing the chlorine residual down. If it dilutes too much, you have no oxidation. There are 2 way to prevent this...1. Use a flow switch or place the injection point before the pressure tank. Also, IMO, the spun filter should be after the softener. Let the carbon filter & softener do the brunt of the work and use the spun filter as a polishing filter. No need for the greensand filter.
 

Mikey

Aspiring Old Fart, EE, computer & networking geek
Messages
3,024
Reaction score
17
Points
38
Location
Hansville, Washington
That's a reason to switch the system around as I'm doing. I'd prefer to base the Cl injection on flow, but flow switches are too expensive. I'd also like to be able to draw water at 3 points -- untreated, de-ironed, and softened -- but then my wellhouse would look like the ballast controls on U-boat. There's a little bit of a mystery in the chlorination system. Even with the Cl residual cranked way up, the ferric iron doesn't precipitate in the holding tank as I would expect -- when I flush the tank, there's little sign of iron. It used to, when the system was installed, but not now. The old-timer that installed it and set up the chlorinator didn't do any formal testing -- he just smelled the water and set the chlorinator pump stroke and that was that. I don't remember the result when I last tested the water, but the iron was a lot smaller than I thought it would be. Going to retest tomorrow, or whenever it stops raining.
 

Mialynette2003

In the Trades
Messages
944
Reaction score
17
Points
18
Location
Ocala, Florida
Sounds like the pH may be low. When the pH drops, iron will not oxidize out of the water. Even though chlorine will raise the pH somewhat, you may need a neutralizer before the filter equipment. When I drain a retention tank, I shake the tank when the water gets about 1/4 from empty. It will stir whatever is on the bottom.
 

Mikey

Aspiring Old Fart, EE, computer & networking geek
Messages
3,024
Reaction score
17
Points
38
Location
Hansville, Washington
Yeah -- another thing to check. At one time, it was high -- 7.6, as I remember -- but I haven't checked it in a long while. I'll try to run all the tests today, but tomorrow is more likely. The designer of the contact tank thoughtfully set the drain about 10" above the bottom, which is concave, so it won't naturally drain completely on its own. So, when I clean it, I drain it, disconnect it from the system, take it outside and use the pressure washer on it. Inverted, it drains completely. Haven't seen any real sediment in years, although it used to be "normal", and the first few seconds of draining produced nice rusty goop.

Test results on 9/9/2001:
At wellhead - 8gpG hardness (drop count titration)
0.9 mg/L Fe (Phenantoline method)
7.5 pH
0.0 H2S (Effervescence test, Hach HS-C)
Post chlorination - 1.3 mg/L Cl (DPD Total Cl)
In house - 0 hardness, Iron, and Chlorine
7.5 pH
Tests for bacteria at the wellhead are cooking.
 
Last edited:
Top
Hey, wait a minute.

This is awkward, but...

It looks like you're using an ad blocker. We get it, but (1) terrylove.com can't live without ads, and (2) ad blockers can cause issues with videos and comments. If you'd like to support the site, please allow ads.

If any particular ad is your REASON for blocking ads, please let us know. We might be able to do something about it. Thanks.
I've Disabled AdBlock    No Thanks