Is this stack up legal?

TomWS · May 22, 2011

The house was built in 2006 so could be either UPC 2006 or earlier. If we ignore the metal strap hangers and the wire dangling under the pipe, is the Wye and the 45 degree stack a proper setup? It seems 'unusual' to me...

The reason I ask is that I'm about to get some additional plumbing installed and I don't want the Inspector noticing this and forcing us to change it at our expense (I'll hire the original plumber in that case and he can fix anything not meeting code at his expense).

Terry · May 22, 2011

As long as the pipe is graded properly, at a 2% grade, then it looks like nice work.
The pipe should be supported every four feet.

Sponsor · 2022-01-29T12:20:58-0800

TomWS · May 22, 2011

Thanks! You've taken a load off my mind!

hj · May 23, 2011

quote; I'll hire the original plumber in that case and he can fix anything not meeting code at his expense).

Good luck with that after 5 years, especially if it was inspected at that time.

Dlarrivee · May 23, 2011

Good luck is right... what world do you live in?

TomWS · May 23, 2011

I live in a fantasy world where things that aren't right are made right...

hj · May 23, 2011

quote; I live in a fantasy world where things that aren't right are made right...

That is an "ideal". In the real world, things are "made right", but after a year, you pay for them.

Dlarrivee · May 23, 2011

TomWS said:
I live in a fantasy world where things that aren't right are made right...

And you buy a 5 year old home, but expect the people involved with the build originally to come out of the woodwork and fix things that you think are done wrong?

TomWS · May 23, 2011

If you read OP then you'd know I was referring to a condition that AHJ thought was wrong and, last I checked, he has the final word.

hj · May 24, 2011

quote; If you read OP then you'd know I was referring to a condition that AHJ thought was wrong

Correction. It was a condition the HOMEOWNER thought was wrong, and after a year, (two in this area),the original contractor had NO LIABILITY to redo it. He, nor I, would change it unless the owner was willing to pay for the work, and in this case I might insist on payment up front so he could not "change his mind" after the work was completed. But this is all acedemic, since there is nothing defective about the existing installation, at least in the picture which was posted.

TomWS · May 24, 2011

Just so we're clear, you are right. I saw this stack up and THOUGHT is was, to quote EXACTLY, "unusual".

Two things came to mind. IF it WAS wrong, AHJ COULD ask for it to be fixed because it had been missed in the original inspection. TWO, since I wasn't sure it was wrong, I came here to consult with the EXPERTs for an opinion BEFORE I acted on MY opinion and got a very straightforward and useful one from Terry. End of the 'real story'.

I didn't come here to have a philosophical discussion on whether a professional plumber has a duty to meet code with their work, two days or five years after the work is done. Obviously we have a differing opinion on that matter - all of which is totally irrelevant to the original question.

Cwhyu2 · May 24, 2011

TomWS said:
The house was built in 2006 so could be either UPC 2006 or earlier. If we ignore the metal strap hangers and the wire dangling under the pipe, is the Wye and the 45 degree stack a proper setup? It seems 'unusual' to me...

The reason I ask is that I'm about to get some additional plumbing installed and I don't want the Inspector noticing this and forcing us to change it at our expense (I'll hire the original plumber in that case and he can fix anything not meeting code at his expense).

That work looks fine.

hj · May 24, 2011

quote; Obviously we have a differing opinion on that matter - all of which is totally irrelevant to the original question.

It is NOT irrelevent when you start talking about having "the original plumber fix it at his own expense". At that point it becomes VERY relevent.

Is this stack up legal?

Users who are viewing this thread

TomWS

New Member

Attachments

Terry

The Plumbing Wizard

Sponsor

Paid Advertisement

TomWS

New Member

hj

Master Plumber

Dlarrivee

New Member

TomWS

New Member

hj

Master Plumber

Dlarrivee

New Member

TomWS

New Member

hj

Master Plumber

TomWS

New Member

Cwhyu2

Consultant

hj

Master Plumber

Similar threads