You should be fine.
You may want to use silicone instead of putty with the acrylic tub though.
I have never installed a acrylic tub (or any other type for that matter) and had a concern about the underside of the tub I purchased. I understand that the drain shoe has a rubber gasket that goes between the shoe flange and the underside of the tub but the tub but wondered if the underside of my tub will cause a problem. Notice the flattened of area where it was ground flat at the factory. That seems allright but on the left side of the the opening in the photo it drops lower and was not touched when the rest was ground. Is this a problem or the norm for an acrylic tub?
I assume the plumbers putty under the flange of the drain will provide adequate leak proofing when it is screwed down into the shoe, so I'm hoping the professionals here think this tub is ok like this.
Crossing my fingers as this is tub number 2 that I've ordered.
The putty under the flange has nothing to do with sealing. It is just a cushion. ( Well, it might help, but the rubber MUST make a seal). That fat rubber gasket under the tub is the seal. I would try to sand the tub a little smoother, and possibly use some silicone with that gasket.
The gasket on the bottom does ALL the leakproof sealing. UNLESS the gasket mates to the entire surface, (at some point not necessarily the entire width of the gasket), it will leak. Silicone between the gasket and the tub will probably seal it, but also make it impossible to remove at a later date if necessary.