Is this water closet drain vented properly?

[mjsmith0]

Here are a couple pictures of the plumbing for my water closet. (One is dry fit and the other shows it installed). Does this look like it's vented this properly? (The vent pipe will extend 4-5' farther up before it turns.)

Thanks in advance!

[cacher_chick]

A vent cannot run horizontally until it is a minimum of 6" above the flood rim of the highest fixture.

[jimbo]

Unfortunately that is a VERY BIG NO. That fails inspeciton for the very real reason that such a horizontal vent would very soon be clogged with waste.

[mjsmith0]

Darn, I was afraid of that. Thanks for saving me from a big mistake. I got the idea of venting it this way from the a DIY webpage:

http://www.diyadvice.com/diy/plumbin...in-vent-lines/
I guess it's wrong?

Mary

[jc60618]

The last illustration would pass inspection in Chicago, I dont know about your area.The pictures you posted before wouldnt because you had those two fiitings raising the quarter bend above the vent. But like I said this last illustration would pass in Chicago. We often vent suspended toilets, p-traps or showers this way.

[mjsmith0]

Gotcha. It makes sense to me now. Probably should have realized that before. Thanks!

[shacko]

Darn, I was afraid of that. Thanks for saving me from a big mistake. I got the idea of venting it this way from the a DIY webpage:

http://www.diyadvice.com/diy/plumbin...in-vent-lines/
I guess it's wrong?

Mary

Under the UPC you can run a flat vent the way it's shown, you just have to add a clean-out on the vent where it comes up in the wall.

[mjsmith0]

Here is a variation on that design that would fit in the space I have. It is somewhat like the design I found on DIY site I showed above, but with a twist (literally!) I wonder if its too much of a pretzel?

Thanks everyone for your patience and help while I try to figure this out!