PDA

View Full Version : Quietest toilet?



garrry
03-14-2006, 01:56 AM
Because the one bathroom in my house is right next to the living room, I wanted the quietest flush possible. I installed a Kohler Rialto, which is very quiet; it barely murmurs when you flush it.

Unfortunately, that's its only good quality. Double flush is almost always necessary, bowl wash is terrible, etc.

So I want to replace it. I'm not too worried about clogs, but I want a toilet that will get it all the first time and clean the bowl decently. But I want one with a quiet flush -- I'm not so much concerned with the tank fill noise as with the flush itself. Any opinions on what toilet has the absolutely quietest flush?

Thanks! And thanks Terry, this is an incredible resource.

prashster
03-14-2006, 06:08 AM
Why are you not concerned with the tank fill as much as the flush? The flush takes 2 seconds. The refill is an order of magnitude longer.

If it were me, I wouldn't worry about the noise so much. A clean, quick flush is better than a slow, sloppy one.

If you really want quiet, you could always cut out the floor and install a composting toilet. Those flies can tickle, though ;)

jimbo
03-14-2006, 07:25 AM
One piece toilets are usually qiieter, especially models like the Rialto which use a "swirl" type flushing action.

jdkimes
03-14-2006, 11:18 AM
The Toto Drake with Sanagloss.
The noise from a flush is not always from the toilet. There's the issue of the drain/soil pipes...cast iron is nearly silent but ABS is noisy and you can hear every drop trickle through.
There's the water supply...pipes that touch or are tight up against the structure will make noise in the walls.
Go with a quick flush and a quick fill which is the Drake, with Sanagloss keeps the bowl clean.
I agree with Garry, if you want silence and no bowl streaks go with a port-a-potty. But then you have to have those guys come once a weak to suction it clean, that can be annoying ;)

garrry
03-14-2006, 06:10 PM
I'm more concerned with the flush than the fill because the sound of running water if I'm serving dinner is not as disconcerting as the archie bunker sound of flushing.

Plumbing is cast iron.

I agree that i don't want a sloppy flush. I was hoping to get both quiet and neat. Is that not a possibility?

As to the one piece-two piece idea -- would an ultramax be quieter than a drake, for example? Are there any swirl-flush toilets that actually work?

jk60
03-14-2006, 07:58 PM
I've installed two toilets about 3 months ago. A Toto Ultramax and a Kohler San Raphael. I prefer the Toto Ultramax in terms of performance but the Kohler is quieter. Neither toilet has given us any problems - no double flushes and the bowl stays clean. Given the choice I would go with the Toto Ultramax but if sound is the main criteria, Kohler San Raphael would be an acceptable choice for me. It has an ingenium flushing system which may be different then the one in your Rialto toilet.

Mike50
03-15-2006, 05:56 PM
I'm more concerned with the flush than the fill because the sound of running water if I'm serving dinner is not as disconcerting as the archie bunker sound of flushing.

That's an interesting metaphor.
But flushing is one of those great socio-economic equalizers. Can't get around it.
reminds me of a quote:

"You aren't any safer in first class"

Maybe Maxwell Smart's Cone of silence is the only solution... :D

garrry
03-16-2006, 05:44 PM
OK. I couldn't deal with both the social commentary and the wisecracks, so I bought a Drake this afternooon. (appreciate the San Raphael recommendation, JK60, but other people's experience with the Ingenium have been uneven, and I didn't want to risk it.) i supose I prefer loud rude noises to little surprises floating in the bowl...

jk60
03-16-2006, 05:58 PM
Garrry - I agree, loud rude noises are definitely better then little surprises floating in the bowl. Luckily I haven't seen that as yet. No experience with the Drake, but if it's anything like the Ultramax you'll be happy.

bigfoot
03-19-2006, 03:39 AM
I do not know why more people do not put in a wall thick enough for 5.5 inches of insulation. There is the other important aspect as to where a toilet is placed in the design of the house. Try some insulation around the toilet if this works, pull the toilet cut out the sheet rock and fill the void. Or if you now the void is open, cut a hole in the top of the wall and blow in insullaiton.
Good luck. :D

garrry
03-22-2006, 08:29 PM
That's a good suggestion. But blowing insulation into the spaces behind sheetrock with fireblocks between the studs is a major pain, and besides there is the matter of the door. Maybe some kind of bank vault thing...