HJ,
Thanks for your advice. I guess I've been on a bit of a snipe hunt and just needed to apply some ingenuity.
Let me explain my situation a bit further and make sure I completely understand your suggestion.
I am in a complete remodel situation where the walls are bare to the studs and the plumbing is being redone, so I have some flexibility. Also, the kitchen is over an unfinished basement, so I have some lattitude in where the drain pipes go.
If I read your advice correctly you would prefer the 2 drain scenario, i.e. plumb the center bowl/garbage disposal/dishwasher + one of the large bowls like a standard 2 bowl sink to its own trap and drain and then plumb the remaining large bowl like a single bowl sink to its own trap and drain. Am I correct in my understanding?
If so, I have a couple of questions about the 2 drains.
1. I would just drop the 2 drains into the basement and connect up to a properly sloped horizontal run heading toward the main building drain, correct? I'm in an outside wall which will not allow me to drop straight down to connect to the horizontal run (interference with the rim joist, foundation, etc.). Is it OK to use some combination of bend fittings (say 1/8 or 1/16 bends) and pipe stubs to come away from the foundation at an angle and then go vertical again to hit the branch of a combo wye in the horizontal run? Probably a good idea to put a cleanout in the upper end of the highest wye as well?
2. The sink is under a double window (of course) which is in the way of the ideal, vertical vent. I believe this means I have to come up vertically as high as I can above the flood rim of the sink and then head horizontal (with proper slope upwards) until clear of the window and then turn vertical up to the roof as soon as possible.
Can I run both of the vents, from the tops of the drain sanitary T's, vertically into the horizontal run? I would connect to the lower end of the horizontal vent line with a vent el and the middle of the horizontal run with a combo wye. The horizontal run would then continue until clear of the window and connect to the vertical line to the roof via another vent el.
3. My only other concern is I'm not sure I can squeeze the dishwasher drain line into the garbage disposal port with it up under that middle sink. It's kind of tight in there. If this is the case would you suggest plugging the garbage disposal dishwasher port and using a sink drain assembly with the dishwasher port? Those flexible dishwaser hoses and drain port connections have always seemed so cheap looking to me, i.e. a leak waiting to happen. Is there a better way to do it or am I being over concerned?
I hope that is clear.
Thanks again for the advice.
Joel