Experience with Stevens sump pumps?

[Yesnik49]

My local plumbing supply is pushing Stevens sump pumps, I am inclined to use a Zoeller n53 but I can't find a good piggyback switch locally. the supply guy likes the diaphram switch design that Stevens uses. I would like to get opinions on this.

also Stevens gives a 7 year warranty, Zoeller is one year. Seems that Zoeller could afford to offer a better warranty if their quality is as good as touted.

[Ian Gills]

What's wrong with using a Zoeller with a built-in switch?

I simply do not believe that for ordinary use the switch is a problem. My last Zoeller lasted 16 years and was still going (but rusty) when I replaced it.

I would only consider a seprerate switch for a sump pump that was running 24/7 i.e. a basement with serious water issues. But for most of us, when the sump runs only when it rains, the built-in switch is fine, depsite what other posters might say.

[speedbump]

I have never liked diaphragm switches. They aren't to be trusted. Floats however are very trustworthy if installed properly.

[mattbee24]

We have been selling Stevens pumps for about 20 years now. Very few problems with them. We might get back 1 out of every 100 we sell under warranty.

[bubb1957]

The switch on my Zoeller m53 lasted about 6 months in a very active sump pit. I put on an external swith for the Zoeller, and I really think the pump itself would last forever, I have it ready as a back up. My Stevens SS57 has lasted about a year so far. I have doubts that it will last 7 years, but if not, I will get a new one under warranty for another 7 years.

[master plumber mark]

I dont like the stevens becasue I remember that
only one wire plugs into the wall and if the diaphram
switch fails then the pump is done..

I prefer a two wire deal where you can still plug the
pump into the power and advert disaster...
at 2am in the morning......





the Zoeller pump is a better pump...

their switch absolutely sucks, but the pump will proably run forever..



I have posted my solution before

you can buy the Zoeller motor only and just add

the SJE verticle switch....


http://onsmartpages.com/weilhammerplumbingco/nss-folder/pictures/si_UEw80h80_DSC08743.jpg (http://onsmartpages.com/weilhammerplumbingco/pictures/view_alone.nhtml?profile=pictures&UID=10133) you can also adjust the height to come on less oftern

Now, you would think by now that Zoeller would sell this in a package to compete with others like hydromatic..

.but for some reason they will not admit a design flaw in that crappy switch they have sold for decades....


I guess if you make something too good, then you dont have people comming back for repeat business...


http://www.weilhammerplumbing.com/sumppumps/

[bubb1957]

mattbee..check your PM

[bubb1957]

just an update of the stevens ss57, still going strong for about 3 years, flawless. A record for my active sump pit. I have had a Zoeller m53 on the shelf for years, but would never use a Zoeller unless I put on an external switch. Zoeller pumps will run forever, but like most others, the switch wont last in my pit