PDA

View Full Version : which is more efficient?



GabeS
05-31-2009, 12:52 PM
Hi,

I'm going to buy an air conditioner and am trying to figure out which has a lower operating cost. The AC that is 110 volts or the AC that is 220 volts. The 110 is 15,000 BTU and the 220 is 18,000 BTU, but lets just pretend they are exactly the same BTU.

Is the 220 more energy efficient because it uses less amps or are they exactly the same?

Thanks.

Gabe

jimbo
05-31-2009, 12:55 PM
Other things being equal, they consume the same WATTS, which is what you pay for. 10 amps at 120 volts is 1200 watts. 5 amps at 240 is also 1200 watts. There are some advantages like for the same KW energy usage, you could use smaller wires, and since given same wire size, the higher amp unit would produce more heat ( I-squared_R) , and heat is wasted energy.

In the case of a window air conditioner, none of the above would be anything to lose sleep over.

Thatguy
05-31-2009, 06:35 PM
I'm going to buy an air conditioner and am trying to figure out which has a lower operating cost.
The 110 is 15,000 BTU and
the 220 is 18,000 BTU
Is the 220 more energy efficient because it uses less amps or are they exactly the same?

15000 BTU/hr = ~4400 watts. If it only pulls 1200 watts (1200/110 = 11A) from the wall the Coefficient Of Performance [COP] is 4400/1200 = 3.7.
If the 18000 pulls 1200w (1200/220 = 5.5A) it's COP is 5300/1200 = 4.4 so it's more efficient.

Look on the nameplates to see how many amps each of these draw. Due to Economy of Scale I'd expect the 18000 would have a higher COP.