View Full Version : Ever see a lead toilet connection like this before?
dimprov
02-17-2009, 05:23 AM
It apparently penetrats the slab, and then somehow was grafted/soldered to regular 3" PVC below. But how did they do it?
I presume they used lead because it could deform (which, as you can see, it apparently did) when the slab was poured and subsequently expanded? But why go to such an elaborate method?
David
The fact that the lead could deform would be one reason NOT to use it. And without seeing how they made the transition, we cannot tell you how they did it.
dimprov
02-17-2009, 07:08 PM
I guess you mean the transition at the bottom? I toook some closer photos. I could post if it might shed any light.
What would be the motivation for using this type of connection? The house is vintage 2001 built by a major, publicly traded builder, not some crackerjack outfit.
David
One motivation could be that he was being paid time and material and that not only took some expensive material, but I can guarantee it also took more time than doing it the right way.
CarlH
02-18-2009, 04:48 PM
The house is vintage 2001 built by a major, publicly traded builder, not some crackerjack outfit.
Have you seen the people these publicly traded outfits hire to build their homes? The cheapest bidder gets the contract. Some of these contractors can be crackerjack outfits. I'd much rather have a smaller builder who has a reputation to uphold. The big builders are driven more by profits and share holder value.
thezster
02-18-2009, 04:58 PM
wow.. that's pretty incredible, considering it was 2001. As the owner of a "fix n flip" company averaging numerous turnarounds per year - I know that I often dig through my "inventory" of leftovers to finish a new job... but I'd never resort to this kind of "crap"..... some things should go to the trash heap.. and anything requiring lead is one of them....
What's holding that flange in place?
What makes you think the lead is attached to the PVC? The lead "top hats" used with CI aren't.
Ater seeing the "quality work" done by Fix and Flip contractors on the "Flip this House" TV program, I would not advertise too loudly that you were one of them.
thezster
02-19-2009, 06:11 AM
Those TV shows give professionals a bad name. Some of us strive for quality work in every aspect of our renovations... Even bothering to permit our projects.
SewerRatz
02-19-2009, 07:05 AM
wow.. that's pretty incredible, considering it was 2001. As the owner of a "fix n flip" company averaging numerous turnarounds per year - I know that I often dig through my "inventory" of leftovers to finish a new job... but I'd never resort to this kind of "crap"..... some things should go to the trash heap.. and anything requiring lead is one of them....
Hey now I still prefer to use lead and oakum, and even lead flashings.
thezster
02-19-2009, 08:57 AM
Hey now I still prefer to use lead and oakum, and even lead flashings.
No offense intended... and I apologize if I offended you.... Maybe it's because I don't know how to work with lead/oakum... and prefer the simplicity of plastic..... But - I digress... and the thread should move back to the intended question...
xroad
02-21-2009, 06:41 PM
My mother's 100 year old house had lead pipe like that. Toilet sits on a wax ring sealthat sits on the lead "flared" end of pipe and eventually mates up the cast iron.
Lead to cast iron was the way it was done 100 years ago. I don't think that lead to PVC has ever been an approved method.
C NUMB
02-22-2009, 06:35 AM
Lead to cast iron was the way it was done 100 years ago.
And I wish it would come back to that, that was a form of art. My lead pot and tools set in a room in my office, and I ask pending applicants if they have any clue as to what they are, you should hear some of the replies.
Propane or naptha/white gas furnace?