View Full Version : Will this level entry shower design work?
02-03-2009, 11:46 AM
I could use some advice on whether a remodel design for a level entry shower will work. Basically:
beforeF.png is the as-built floorplan for a guest bathroom and part of a laundry.room.
beforeR.jpg is a rendering of the as-built guest bathroom.
afterF.jpg is the remodelled guest bathroom. It steals some space from the laundry room, and adds two linear drains.
afterR.jpg is the corresponding rendering.
now.jpg is in-between before and after. It is a photo I took after doing some forensic demolition this past Saturday of the as-built bathtub.
Why "forensic" demolition? Because I wanted to locate the bath trap and its relationship to some post-tension cables running through the slab. As best I could using the instruments I had, I located the post-tension cables and marked their location on the concrete slab using a red marker. I also represented them on the floorplans using red lines.
So, here's the issue: the drain for the just demolished bathtub is on the "wrong" side of the post-tension cables vis-a-vis the linear drain I want to install. However, it seems that if I used two separate linear drains, I could tie one into the waste line currently used by the soon-to-be demolished laundry-room sink, and the other I could (I hope) tie into the toilet's waste line, which I have to move 4 inches anyway to give more elbowroom in the shower. By doing it this way, I could can steer clear of the post-tension cables.
Does this approach to the plumbing seem feasible, or would it break some obvious international building code (like maybe connecting a shower waste lline too close to a toilet waste line or something)?
If it doesn't break code, then this design has the side benefit of providing a sort of drain redundancy (reserve/backup drain) for the remodelled level-entry shower. For instance, if one drain got clogged with hair, then the other drain could catch the overflow.
I guess this means you either did not read, or intend to disregard the notice in your garage floor stating, "Post tension slab. DO NOT drill or make holes in the floor."
02-04-2009, 09:02 AM
In order to make the curbless shower, you have to slope the floor to your drain. The only way you can do that is to cut the slab out in the shower, redo it lower, and build you mudbed on top of that. You cannot cut your slab out so that's irrelevant. Besides all that, you need a 2" drain line for the shower which you cannot change to without tearing out the slab that you cannot tear out. Sorry, but without EXTENSIVE work, you're SOL.
02-04-2009, 06:40 PM
Thanks for your feedback.
Nope, HJ, I didn't see any such notice either in or on the garage floor. Is that where critical warnings get pasted in Arizona nowadays? :) I grew up in Tucson and can't remember seeing any then either.
OK, I accept that this may not be a cakewalk, but is it really all that dire? Does any of the following information change your mind regarding feasibility?
1. As for Iminaquagmire's second point, I'm lucky in that Drain #1 (the drain from the demolished laundry room sink) is 2" diameter. See attachment afterF2.jpg. For the reasons indicated at the start of this thread, I wasn't planning to involve the bathtub drain (drain #3) in draining the shower.
2. The load bearing walls stand directly over stemwalls.
3. The slab immediately around the trap for the as-built bathtub drain (drain #3) is at least 8" thick. It seems that there is rebar in the slab around that location because part of the rebar was exposed by whoever jackhammered that portion of the trap, and because my measuring instrument shows there to be a few other pieces in that area at a depth of around 3 to 4 inches. The exposed piece looks like 1/2" rebar.
4. As for Iminaquagmire's first point, I was planning to use either Kerdi or Noble (see attachment thinbed.jpg) to construct a thin bed shower on top of the slab that would drain in a monoplane from the back wall toward the linear drains (scupper- drains/trough-drains/trench-drains/whatever-name-you-want-to-call-it). I figured that way I wouldn't need to recess the shower bed into the slab. This means that the floor at the back wall (shown as the yellow wall at the bottom of the picture) would be about 3/4" higher than the top of the linear drain so that the floor can slope 1/4" per foot toward the linear drain. Of course, space for the linear drains, P-trap's, and piping to Drain #1 and Drain #2 would still need to be carved out from the slab. This might resemble two T's, if viewed from the sink looking toward the back wall.
5. I'm not quite sure why HJ referred to the garage slab, but if it makes any difference the top of the garage slab is 5 feet below the top of the bathroom slab. To better orient you, attached is a glasshouse view of the remodelled bathroom as seen from the garage. Also attached is a backclipped cross-section that shows the relationship.
02-04-2009, 09:07 PM
The warning is usually stamped into the garage slab someplace. That's what he meant.
I'm trying to wrap my head around how you plan to put the drain in for the shower, linear or not. They are not just flat drains, and even if they were, they still need a trap, which needs to be recessed if you want a barrier free shower. I see no way of putting in any sort of drain and running any length of pipe connecting it to anything without breaking out concrete. Seems to me that your cables are in the way of every conceivable configuration. Could you possibly post some pictures of your shower area from different angles showing the boundaries and their relationship to the cables. Also, post some pictures of the drain setup from the "demolished" laundry room.
The warning is stamped into the garage floor slab and often in the outdoor sidewalks also, but it applies to the ENTIRE building. The idea being to make it so noticeable that homeowners do NOT start chopping the floor and doing remodeling. HOW you do what you are asking, will determine whether it is legal or not, and codes usually just define HOW you can do things. What did your building department say about you breaking into the floor for these revisions, which DO require a building permit and inspections?
02-05-2009, 04:47 PM
Also, post some pictures of the drain setup from the "demolished" laundry room.
OK, photos are attached. The last photo shows the current arrangement for the laundry sink that's on the other side of the wall.
02-05-2009, 05:12 PM
What did your building department say about you breaking into the floor for these revisions, which DO require a building permit and inspections?
They said they're not a help desk. They said pay a fee and submit a plan for approval. They said it must satify these codes:
2006 International Residential Code - Residential Building and Mechanical Construction
2003 Uniform Plumbing Code - Residential and Commercial Construction
2005 National Electrical Code - All electrical installations
Usually they ARE a help desk to civilians who are not contractors or engineers. But I guess this is a case where you might not find out you have a problem until the inspector turns it down. In this case, all you can do is draw the plumbing the way you think it will work and then get a permit. The permit will be stamped, "This permit approves the drawing as submitted, BUT does not, however, allow any installation which violates any sections of the building code", or something similar which is a CYA ALL permits include so the department cannot be charged with allowing violations if found at a later date. If the permit approves it but the inspector does not like it you are SOL, and will have to regroup and try again. The problem being, if he has a problem with you breaking a poststressed floor, there is NO way to correct it.
02-06-2009, 10:53 AM
Considering the possible consequences, it appears to me that hiring a professional contractor would be a prudent choice. At least get a professional opinion from someone familiar with local codes.
02-06-2009, 09:58 PM
Very well, assume for the moment that I hired a licensed structural engineer and assume that he said that changes to the slab are a non-issue. Are there any plumbing gotchas in what I've proposed?
02-07-2009, 08:06 AM
Well, the laundry drain may already tie into the same lateral that the toilet drains into, so there is probably little real advantage from that standpoint in having two drains in the shower.
Also, using linear drains, or actually any type of drain, you do involve one of the three inviolable principles of plumbing: water flows down hill. SO how do you arrange the slope of the floor to accompodate that?
If you do have post tension cables located per your lines, I wonder how much slab-breaking you would be allowed to do, so close to the cable. You MUST get this issue resolved.
02-07-2009, 07:17 PM
It can be VERY dangerous, and detrimental to the entire structure if you compromise a cable or the supporting structure around a cable (i.e., the slab). You need someone who really understands this and can work out the math and maybe more important, has a bond large enough to cover whatever damage that may occur if he gets it wrong up to having the house condemmed.
02-08-2009, 05:35 AM
Another note, that second drain would require a trap primer. In my area a shower without curb requires 2" from finish floor to top of shower drain with at least a 1/2" step down.
02-08-2009, 09:59 AM
I don't see an engineer saying it's okay to cut past the pre-stressed cables.
I would like to see that one in writing.
There are many shower pans that locate the drain near one end of the shower.
If you forget about perfectly centering the drain, put it where it can go, and then sloping toward the drain, you are much better off.
You may want to ask this at the JohnBridge (http://www.johnbridge.com) about how the pan would work in your situation.
We can advise on plumbing, but they have better tile setters.
02-08-2009, 02:12 PM
Thanks for the feedback.
1. Are you sure a trap primer is required? If so, I'm guessing it's to mitigate a vacuum effect that might empty the shower p-trap on Drain #2 when the toilet flushes? Wouldn't proper venting prevent that from happening?
2. This is the first I've heard of a 2" requirement from the finish floor to top of shower drain. Is this a common plumbing requirement? NOW you've got me worried. This could be the unknown project-killer I was worried might be lurking. I had thought that aside from p-traps, 2" drain diameters, and adequate venting, the only plumbing requirement was for a 1/4" slope toward the drain. This shower is NOT attempting to be an ADA shower, and it is NOT attempting to be wheel chair accessible, but even when I look at those documents, it looks like only a 1" drop is involved (see attached), and I had assumed that was because 4' of space was needed to park the wheelchair (i.e. 4 feet x 1/4"/foot = 1"). Granted, these drawings aren't plumbing code...
3. You mean a 1/2" step down from the "high point" (see attached photo for reference)? You mean a 1/2" "ramp-down" instead of step-down would not suffice? Does anyone know if this is a common plumbing code (if that's what it is)? Again, I haven't seen it in any of the curbless shower drawings I've seen... In fact, it doesn't even sound curbless. More like a mini-curb.
07-22-2009, 12:36 AM
As I see it the exsiting ptrap is exposed and the damage is done. I would see if its possible to tie into the exsiting 2" ptrap with the kerdi drain and see how tight that can be mounted to the floor.
Then bring in your tile guy and tiles and see what slope you need to run the water well. I would be raising the level of the floor near the vantity 1" and grading that back to the entry, keep the area near the toilet and vanity flat then grade everything back to the drain.
It is a multi step process but getting the grade right then waterpoofing on top with the ditra and kerdi cloth will make the install bullet tight.
Water test your design before setting any tile....