thedanned
New Member
Hello
Got a couple three questions about ABS vs. PVC piping. First, I would like to mention that this is not for an actual plumbing project. But after reading up on a few threads, it seems like you people know your ish when it comes to building materials. And yes, I have gone to home depot and the like to ask these questions and all I get is a blank stare then the guy just repeats himself "well, like I said, this here ABS is for drains..."
What I am doing is making a shipping container for tripods (you know, like for a camera but heavier duty). I'm making about 25 of these. I ship the tripods out over and over again via FedEx. I have made one prototype case out of 6" PVC. Its 30" of pipe, cap on one end and a threaded pipe cap on the other ) to remove the tripod from the case. So about 34" overall. It has gone out and come back twice and survived. I just sent it back out again today, so were working on number three here!
My question is, which do you all think would hold up longer? This case is 15lbs by itself, 21 lbs with the tripod in it. I'm concerned that PVC will shatter if dropped too hard by FedEx. Reading different places online, ABS seems to be lighter and more flexible than PVC as far as impact resistance. And I'd like to cut down on weight a little bit. But 6" ABS is hard to find (at least in New Mexico) whereas 6" PVC is readily available.
So, in order of importance, what Im working with is
Impact resistance (don't want the case to shatter out there somewhere and loose my tripod)
Longevity
Weight
Also, black ABS looks better and I don't have to paint it.
Any input would be greatly appreciated. Also, I know this really isn't the purpose of this forum, but I don't really know where to go for an answer.
Thank you!
Got a couple three questions about ABS vs. PVC piping. First, I would like to mention that this is not for an actual plumbing project. But after reading up on a few threads, it seems like you people know your ish when it comes to building materials. And yes, I have gone to home depot and the like to ask these questions and all I get is a blank stare then the guy just repeats himself "well, like I said, this here ABS is for drains..."
What I am doing is making a shipping container for tripods (you know, like for a camera but heavier duty). I'm making about 25 of these. I ship the tripods out over and over again via FedEx. I have made one prototype case out of 6" PVC. Its 30" of pipe, cap on one end and a threaded pipe cap on the other ) to remove the tripod from the case. So about 34" overall. It has gone out and come back twice and survived. I just sent it back out again today, so were working on number three here!
My question is, which do you all think would hold up longer? This case is 15lbs by itself, 21 lbs with the tripod in it. I'm concerned that PVC will shatter if dropped too hard by FedEx. Reading different places online, ABS seems to be lighter and more flexible than PVC as far as impact resistance. And I'd like to cut down on weight a little bit. But 6" ABS is hard to find (at least in New Mexico) whereas 6" PVC is readily available.
So, in order of importance, what Im working with is
Impact resistance (don't want the case to shatter out there somewhere and loose my tripod)
Longevity
Weight
Also, black ABS looks better and I don't have to paint it.
Any input would be greatly appreciated. Also, I know this really isn't the purpose of this forum, but I don't really know where to go for an answer.
Thank you!