[Urgent] How to remove an old long closet flange safely?

D

Dexter

New Member

Messages

8

Reaction score

0

Points

0

• Aug 30, 2008

• #1

I'm trying to spend this holiday weekend to replace a new toilet. This house is around 50 years old. I have to use hacksaw blades to cut those bolts. The depth of the flange is 9'' and 4'' width. Is there a way to remove it and replace a new flange?

Thanks for your helps.

 

Attachments

• 
  IMG_8685.jpg

  47.6 KB · Views: 1,298
• 
  IMG_8692.jpg

  55.1 KB · Views: 1,338

Redwood

Master Plumber

Messages

7,335

Reaction score

14

Points

0

Location

Connecticut

• Aug 30, 2008

• #2

That is lead with a wiped joint...
Why are you changing the flange?
Is it leaking or, in the wrong place?

 

Sponsor

Paid Advertisement

• 1 minute ago

• Add bookmark
• ##

 

D

Dexter

New Member

Messages

8

Reaction score

0

Points

0

• Aug 30, 2008

• #3

Because it's too old and the metal almost rip out apart as you can see the second pix.

 

Basement_Lurker

One who lurks

Messages

664

Reaction score

1

Points

0

Location

Victoria, BC

• Aug 31, 2008

• #4

Working with leaded cast iron is hardly a DIY job.

If there are currently no leaks, you should leave everything as it is and use a toilet flange repair ring if you can get your hands on it. Otherwise, you should call in a plumber and not risk getting in over your head and end up having to call one anyways after all the aggravation.

 

hj

Master Plumber

Messages

33,613

Reaction score

1,057

Points

113

Location

Cave Creek, Arizona

Website

www.terrylove.com

• Aug 31, 2008

• #5

flange

The way I would do it would be to remove the brass wiping ferrule and then lead/oakum a piece of cast iron pipe and then lead/oakum a cast iron flange to it. But that is not a DIY job for any but the most masochistic DIY'ers.

 

Last edited by a moderator: Mar 29, 2020

D

Dexter

New Member

Messages

8

Reaction score

0

Points

0

• Aug 31, 2008

• #6

I probably remove the top flange to the floor surface then install 4'' expansion flange. Is it a wise idea to do so?

 

Gary Swart

In the Trades

Messages

8,101

Reaction score

84

Points

48

Location

Yakima, WA

• Aug 31, 2008

• #7

I'd suggest you heed the advise of Basement Lurker and HJ and get professional help. A toilet flange/connection is certainly one thing you want to be done right so that it will last for many years.

 

Redwood

Master Plumber

Messages

7,335

Reaction score

14

Points

0

Location

Connecticut

• Aug 31, 2008

• #8

An expansion flange will not seal properly to the lead..

 

hj

Master Plumber

Messages

33,613

Reaction score

1,057

Points

113

Location

Cave Creek, Arizona

Website

www.terrylove.com

• Sep 1, 2008

• #9

flange

NO! Lead is malleable and will just expand when you try to tighten the flange into it. Other than some East coast areas where they still have dinoaurs, lead closet connections have been obsolete since the 1940's.

 

Redwood

Master Plumber

Messages

7,335

Reaction score

14

Points

0

Location

Connecticut

• Sep 1, 2008

• #10

Actually HJ over here on the right coast we consider lead to be a dinosaur also...
We just have a lot more obsolete plumbing to work with.
I believe in Canada there is still a strong tendency to use lead closet bends, In fact I have seen postings on a Canadian forum where they showed a lead closet bend with a ABS end.... Why I don't know but that is the only area I know of where it is still common.