The number indicates relative thickness of the wax. #1 is the thinnest and is adequate for most installations where the flange is properly situtated on top of the finished floor. Since you have added tile, you may have an issue, depending on the total thickness of tile and underlayment, if any.
The top of the wax placed on the flange must be at least 1/2" above the finished floor. Use this a guide to wax selection. If you added a lot of thickness, you may need to add one or two flange spacers first.